Deciding
When an appliance is worth repairing, and when it is not
If a repair costs more than about a third of the price of a comparable new appliance, replacing it usually makes more sense. The age of the appliance and the part that failed can move that line, and this guide gives the ages and fitted prices to check it yourself.
By Kaif Sharieff, Fixit BLR · published · reviewed
The one-third rule
If the repair costs more than about a third of a comparable new appliance, replacing is usually the better choice. A 6.5 kg front loader selling for around ₹27,999 puts the line near ₹8,999. Treat it as a starting point. It leaves out two things that matter: how old the appliance is, and which part has failed.
How to run the rule on your own appliance
- Find the price of a comparable new model, the same type and size, in a shop or online.
- Divide that price by three. This is your line.
- Compare the repair quote with the line. Below it, repairing usually wins. Above it, replacing usually does.
- Adjust for age, using the list below.
- If the failed part is one of the expensive ones further down, ask what else on the appliance is worn.
How age changes the answer
- Under 5 years. Repair it in almost every case. The expensive parts are not yet at the age when they wear out, so whatever failed is probably the only thing that will.
- 5 to 10 years. It depends on the part. A pump, a valve, a thermostat or a board is worth fixing. A compressor, a drum bearing set or a sealed wash-pump assembly is the point to ask what else on the machine is worn out.
- Over 10 years. Repair the cheap faults and think hard about the expensive ones. Parts get harder to find: a part for a model discontinued 8 or 10 years ago can take a fortnight to arrive, or may not be available at all.
Typical life, and the part that usually ends it
| Appliance | Typical life | The failure that usually ends it | Fitted price |
|---|---|---|---|
| AC, split | 10 to 12 years | Compressor, or a coil pitted in several places | ₹8,999 to ₹23,999 |
| Refrigerator | 10 to 12 years | Compressor, on a single door | ₹3,199 to ₹4,499 |
| Washing machine | 8 to 10 years | Drum bearing and oil seal set | ₹2,499 to ₹6,499 |
| Water purifier | 7 to 10 years | A cracked body or a discontinued model; filters and membranes are consumables | Membrane ₹1,799 to ₹4,199 |
| Geyser | 8 to 10 years | Inner tank corrosion, which is not a repair | Element ₹1,299 to ₹3,199 |
| Microwave | 7 to 9 years | Magnetron, the part that makes the microwaves, sometimes with the transformer | ₹1,899 to ₹3,199 |
| Kitchen chimney | 7 to 10 years | Suction motor | ₹2,099 to ₹6,799 |
| Built-in oven | 10 to 12 years | Main board plus a full door | ₹4,499 to ₹17,999 |
Parts that usually mean replace
- A fridge compressor on a fridge past 10 years. The part, the gas and the labour come to about half the price of an entry-level new fridge, and the rest of the fridge is as old as the part that just failed. See refrigerator repair.
- A washing machine drum bearing on a machine that has already needed other work. It means taking the whole machine apart, and at ₹2,499 to ₹6,499 it also tells you the machine has done a great many cycles. See washing machine repair.
- A corroded geyser tank. It cannot be repaired at any price. The element and the thermostat can be replaced; the tank cannot.
- A microwave magnetron on a solo microwave older than about 8 years, where ₹1,899 to ₹3,199 fitted is close to half the price of a new one. On a convection microwave the same repair is usually worth doing.
Parts that almost never do
Drain pumps, inlet valves, door interlocks, belts, thermostats, heating elements, capacitors, filters and gaskets are routine replacements. They wear out in normal use, most of them fall in the ₹599 to ₹2,199 band fitted, and replacing one tells you nothing about the rest of the appliance.
Count the running cost too
A 12-year-old fridge and a current 5-star one cost different amounts to run. The star label and the yearly units printed on it come from the scheme run by the Bureau of Energy Efficiency, so you can compare the figures on the box. A gap of 200 to 300 units a year, at Bengaluru home tariffs of roughly 5 to 8 rupees a unit, comes to about 1,000 to 2,400 rupees a year. That is worth counting when the repair is a major one and the appliance is already past its typical life.
What happens at the visit
The technician gives you the price before any repair starts, and tells you if the appliance is not worth repairing. If you decide not to go ahead, you pay only the visit fee, from ₹299. The charges page lists every price band and the fitted price of each common part, so you can do this sum before you call anyone.
Questions
What exactly is the one-third rule?
If a repair quote is more than about a third of what a comparable new appliance costs, replacing usually wins. On a ₹27,999 washing machine that line sits near ₹8,999, so a ₹2,199 pump is an easy yes and a ₹6,499 bearing set on a 9-year-old machine is not. Age moves the line: under 5 years almost everything is worth repairing, and over 10 years only the cheap faults are.
How long should each appliance last in Bengaluru?
Fridges and ACs last 10 to 12 years, washing machines and geysers 8 to 10, water purifiers and chimneys 7 to 10, and microwaves 7 to 9. Borewell water at 480 to 560 ppm takes years off anything with a heating element: a geyser in Whitefield that is never descaled can lose its element twice in 5 years before the tank itself fails.
Is a 5-star replacement worth it for the electricity alone?
Only alongside a major repair. A difference of 200 to 300 units a year at roughly 5 to 8 rupees a unit comes to about 1,000 to 2,400 rupees a year, so it takes several years to pay back a ₹29,999 purchase. Run that sum when the quote in front of you is a compressor and the machine is already 10 or 12 years old.
If I decide not to repair, what do I owe?
You pay the visit fee, from ₹299, and nothing else. It covers the visit and the diagnosis. Nothing is added if you turn down the estimate, and nothing is added if our advice is to replace the appliance.
Pages that go with this
Refrigerator repair
We repair fridges that are not cooling, or where only the freezer still works.
Book nowWashing machine repair
We fix machines that will not drain or spin, that leak, or that have gone dead.
Book nowGuide: spare parts
Part grades, fitted prices and the questions to ask.
Read thisWe repair all major appliance brands
We repair every make out of warranty, across Bengaluru. Tap yours to book.
Still not working? Book now, pay after the job.
Tell us what it is doing and we will tell you what it usually is, and what it usually costs, before anyone comes out.


